Saturday, October 24, 2009

Gender War ... Media collusion ??

I read the following news item on Yahoo News today :

It's ok for man to beat wife, say 36 percent of Bangladeshi women
Buzz Up Share
Twitter Delicious Myspace Digg Stumble Upon Facebook
Thu, Oct 22 11:56 AM
Dhaka, Oct 22 (IANS) Thirty-six percent of Bangladeshi women say it is all right for a man to beat his wife if she is disrespectful to elders, goes out without permission or neglects children, states a government survey. It also says that 46 percent of married women in the country are slapped by their husbands.

Nine percent of them justify wife-bashing for refusal to have sex when they do not want to. They feel that denying sex is an acceptable reason for a man to beat up his wife, according to the fifth and latest Bangladesh Demographic and Health Survey (BDHS) 2007.

Four percent of men who were surveyed also justified wife-beating for refusing sex.

Eighteen percent women are forced to have sex by their husbands even if they do not want to.

Women residing in Chittagong in the south and Sylhet in the northeast, the regions where people are outgoing, experience less physical violence compared to women in other divisions.

In a society where joint families are a norm and where two or three generations share a home, disobeying parents-in-law is a major cause of friction among spouses, leading to wife-bashing.

A total of 36 percent women believe that a husband is justified in hitting his wife for any of these reasons, states the survey.

Twenty-four percent women believe that a husband beating up his wife for disobeying elders is justified, followed by 22 percent who believe that arguing with husbands is okay, 18 percent for going out without telling their husbands while 16 percent for neglecting children.

Argumentative wives are another reason for spousal violence. Men are most likely to justify beating their wives if they argue with them (25 percent), followed by showing disrespect to elders (23 percent), The Daily Star newspaper said Thursday.

Like women, men are least likely to say that refusal to have sex (4 percent) is a ground for wife beating. About 16 percent of men feel that neglecting the children or going out without telling them are justifiable reasons for wife beating.

The study showed that the most common act of physical violence is slapping. Forty-six percent married women were being slapped by their husbands.

Almost 17 percent of married women reported that their husbands punch them or with something that can hurt them. Fifteen percent of women are victims of kicking, dragging and beating. An equal percentage reported that their husbands twist their arms or pulled their hair.

Sexual violence is lowest in Sylhet and Khulna while highest in Barisal. Twenty-one percent of married women in Barisal reported sexual violence, followed by 20 percent of women in Dhaka.

Bangladesh Mahila Parishad president Ayesha Khanam told The Daily Star: 'Vigorous campaigns about the rights of women are the best way to stop such violence. This is really unfortunate that male partners or husbands here think that without torturing their female partners, their power is not being exercised.'


I wanted to post a comment on this news article. I clicked on BuzzUp icon, and was taken to the next page. I filled in my comments in the comments field, and noticed that there was a field to fill in the 'code that appears above', but, to my surprise, there was no code that appeared above the field. Which means, that I cannot post the comment !! I then tried other news items, and the code appeared at the right place.
I then went back to the article again, and clicked on BuzzUp icon. This time there was a message that I could not post a comment or BuzzUp this article !
Well ! What could be the reason that the BuzzUp and Post Comment feature on Yahoo web site was working for several news articles, except the above news article ? Hard to imagine that it would be something technical. Collusion ??

The comment I wanted to post on Yahoo web site is as follows :

The reasons mentioned for wife beating are as follows :

- Disrespectful to elders
- Goes out without permission
- Neglects children
- Disobeying parents-in-law
- Argumentative wives
- Refusal to have sex : only four percent of men surveyed justified wife-beating for refusing sex.

The above reasons, (except the last one), are indeed a cause of major concern for any man wanting a good and cohesive family.

Instead of 'Vigorous campaigns about the rights of women are the best way to stop such violence', the best way for any women's organisation would be

- to understand and acknowledge the importance of woman in a man's and his family's life, and
- to ensure that the above listed behaviours, disrupting and threatening the existence of a family, are not indulged in by women.

Which women's rights is Ayesha Khanam talking about ?
Rights to indulge in above listed behaviours ??
It would be most sinful to indulge in promoting such behaviour.

Further, the percentages mentioned in the news are a bit unclear.
Are they the percentage of all married men, or,
are they the percentages of all such married men who encounter above reasons ?

And, what is the PERCENT OF OF INSTANCES WHEN SUCH BEHAVIOUR WAS TOLERATED ?
The news item does not mention that how many times such behaviour was tolerated.

No comments:

Post a Comment